Miracle of the Qur’an – Be careful

We see a continuous flow of mails related with ‘miracles’ of Quran and Hadiths. Some present statistical analysis, some mathematical proofs etc. Although, the analysis performed in some or many cases may partially be true, but there are reservations. Do we really need these kind of proofs for ‘authenticity’ of our religion? Doesn’t it drifts us away from the REAL thing.

I recently received such a mail from my friend.

that s quite interesting but in urdu, so i ll translate a bit of what it says. the email shows a graph with the X-axis being the number of the surah of the Qur’an (in total 114) and the Y axis being the number of ayah of the surah. So for Al-Fatiha, it is the 1st surah (x axis) with 7 ayah (y axis) and that is the place for the dot. surah baqarah would be 2nd surah (x axis) and 286 ayahs (y axis) and this is the place for the 2nd dot etc. and when you make all the dots and combine them you get the arabic word Allah and arabic world Muhammad as a result. both words appear in the same graph (as seen in image 3) and are only separated for ease of readability in image 1 and 2.
and later on it describes how the graph has been done in detail (scientifically and with aid of computers). blabla…didnt read that part.
i just found it quite interesting…

My comments: It look ‘amazing’ initially, but looking into it in detail, it just a matter of carving the ‘desired’ out of set of points. I may be wrong, but to me its just an intentional drawing of lines to get desired results. Just imagine points alone, you can make anything out of it. Example of one such intention is insertion of ‘paish’ and ‘zabar’ of Muhammad (PBUH); no such effort is performed for Allah. Just look at paish carved out of four points. Why these points were joined like that. The trajectory of right side of upper two points is not related to trajectory of left side from same points (How does author claims that it follows some kind of science (for example Neural Network)).

12

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Miracle of the Qur’an – Be careful

  1. Its pathetic to see people using weak logic and half-cooked facts to ‘create’ a miracle for supporting their belief systems.
    we are doing a disservice to Islam by sticking to such efforts.

  2. “It look ‘amazing’ initially, but looking into it in detail, it just a matter of carving the ‘desired’ out of set of points. I may be wrong, but to me its just an intentional drawing of lines to get desired results”

    I agree.

  3. As’salaamu Alaikum,

    I’ve recived these mails too I think for some people such info and proofs are needed

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s